What is Global Argument.net?
Navigating these Argument Maps
Home Window - Ale
What concepts can help us to understand the war?
Who are pro war?
Who are against the war?
2003 Mar Glennon [+]
One War, Many Theories Michael Cohen
2004 mar Ignatieff [+]
2004 Nov Manne [-]
2005 Jan Kagan [+]
2004 Jun Krauthammer [+]
2002 Pollack [+]
2004 May Ash [-]
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
2003 Aug Gray [-]
2003 Dec Chomsky [-]
2003 Feb Walt [-]
2003 Nov Mann [-]
2003 Sep Gaita [-]
2004 Jul Evans [-]
2002 Sep Harries [-]
2003 Feb Mearsheimer [-]
2004 Mar Fukuyama [-]
2003 Feb Waltz K. [-]
How could the Iraq invasion be understood?
What are the war's causes?
2003 Feb Kristol [+]
2005 Jan Freedman [+]
2003 Mar Roberts [+]
2001 Elshtain [-]
2003 Nov Walzer [-]
2004 Jan Friedman [+]
2004 Feb Scruton [+]
What ethical principles are at stake?
What are the war's effects?
What is the power configuration?
What is the role of institutions?
Legitimacy [-]
Legitimacy [+]
Statistical data
Definitions
Violence [-]
Democracy [+]
Weapons [+]
Security [-]
Democracy [-]
Weapons [-]
Security [+]
Violence [+]
UN [-]
UN [+]
Power [+]
Power [-]
Occupation [+]
Occupation [-]
Reconstruction [+]
Reconstruction [-]
See all the Reference Source
G1 Power [+]
G2 Power [-]
G3 Institution [+]
G4 Institution [-]
G5 Norms [+]
G6 Norms [-]
Terrorism [-]
Terrorism [+]
Disarmament [-]
Disarmament [+]
Preemption [+]
Preemption [-]
Freedom [+]
Freedom [-]
Oil [+]
Oil [-]
What is Global Argument.net?
Navigating these Argument Maps
Home Window - Ale
What concepts can help us to understand the war?
Who are pro war?
Who are against the war?
2003 Mar Glennon [+]
One War, Many Theories Michael Cohen
2004 mar Ignatieff [+]
2004 Nov Manne [-]
2005 Jan Kagan [+]
2004 Jun Krauthammer [+]
2002 Pollack [+]
2004 May Ash [-]
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
2003 Aug Gray [-]
2003 Dec Chomsky [-]
2003 Feb Walt [-]
2003 Nov Mann [-]
2003 Sep Gaita [-]
2004 Jul Evans [-]
2002 Sep Harries [-]
2003 Feb Mearsheimer [-]
2004 Mar Fukuyama [-]
2003 Feb Waltz K. [-]
How could the Iraq invasion be understood?
What are the war's causes?
2003 Feb Kristol [+]
2005 Jan Freedman [+]
2003 Mar Roberts [+]
2001 Elshtain [-]
2003 Nov Walzer [-]
2004 Jan Friedman [+]
2004 Feb Scruton [+]
What ethical principles are at stake?
What are the war's effects?
What is the power configuration?
What is the role of institutions?
Legitimacy [-]
Legitimacy [+]
Statistical data
Definitions
Violence [-]
Democracy [+]
Weapons [+]
Security [-]
Democracy [-]
Weapons [-]
Security [+]
Violence [+]
UN [-]
UN [+]
Power [+]
Power [-]
Occupation [+]
Occupation [-]
Reconstruction [+]
Reconstruction [-]
See all the Reference Source
G1 Power [+]
G2 Power [-]
G3 Institution [+]
G4 Institution [-]
G5 Norms [+]
G6 Norms [-]
Terrorism [-]
Terrorism [+]
Disarmament [-]
Disarmament [+]
Preemption [+]
Preemption [-]
Freedom [+]
Freedom [-]
Oil [+]
Oil [-]

Before navegating in the maps about Iraq war, see the descriptions of the icons and number of nodes...

What is Global Argument.net?
Navigating these Argument Maps
Home Window - Ale
What concepts can help us to understand the war?
Who are pro war?
Who are against the war?
2003 Mar Glennon [+]
One War, Many Theories Michael Cohen
2004 mar Ignatieff [+]
2004 Nov Manne [-]
2005 Jan Kagan [+]
2004 Jun Krauthammer [+]
2002 Pollack [+]
2004 May Ash [-]
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
2003 Aug Gray [-]
2003 Dec Chomsky [-]
2003 Feb Walt [-]
2003 Nov Mann [-]
2003 Sep Gaita [-]
2004 Jul Evans [-]
2002 Sep Harries [-]
2003 Feb Mearsheimer [-]
2004 Mar Fukuyama [-]
2003 Feb Waltz K. [-]
How could the Iraq invasion be understood?
What are the war's causes?
2003 Feb Kristol [+]
2005 Jan Freedman [+]
2003 Mar Roberts [+]
2001 Elshtain [-]
2003 Nov Walzer [-]
2004 Jan Friedman [+]
2004 Feb Scruton [+]
What ethical principles are at stake?
What are the war's effects?
What is the power configuration?
What is the role of institutions?
Legitimacy [-]
Legitimacy [+]
Statistical data
Definitions
Violence [-]
Democracy [+]
Weapons [+]
Security [-]
Democracy [-]
Weapons [-]
Security [+]
Violence [+]
UN [-]
UN [+]
Power [+]
Power [-]
Occupation [+]
Occupation [-]
Reconstruction [+]
Reconstruction [-]
See all the Reference Source
G1 Power [+]
G2 Power [-]
G3 Institution [+]
G4 Institution [-]
G5 Norms [+]
G6 Norms [-]
Terrorism [-]
Terrorism [+]
Disarmament [-]
Disarmament [+]
Preemption [+]
Preemption [-]
Freedom [+]
Freedom [-]
Oil [+]
Oil [-]

Firstly, the body of arguments is organised around three central concepts that dominate mainstream i...

What is Global Argument.net?
Navigating these Argument Maps
Home Window - Ale
What concepts can help us to understand the war?
Who are pro war?
Who are against the war?
2003 Mar Glennon [+]
One War, Many Theories Michael Cohen
2004 mar Ignatieff [+]
2004 Nov Manne [-]
2005 Jan Kagan [+]
2004 Jun Krauthammer [+]
2002 Pollack [+]
2004 May Ash [-]
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
2003 Aug Gray [-]
2003 Dec Chomsky [-]
2003 Feb Walt [-]
2003 Nov Mann [-]
2003 Sep Gaita [-]
2004 Jul Evans [-]
2002 Sep Harries [-]
2003 Feb Mearsheimer [-]
2004 Mar Fukuyama [-]
2003 Feb Waltz K. [-]
How could the Iraq invasion be understood?
What are the war's causes?
2003 Feb Kristol [+]
2005 Jan Freedman [+]
2003 Mar Roberts [+]
2001 Elshtain [-]
2003 Nov Walzer [-]
2004 Jan Friedman [+]
2004 Feb Scruton [+]
What ethical principles are at stake?
What are the war's effects?
What is the power configuration?
What is the role of institutions?
Legitimacy [-]
Legitimacy [+]
Statistical data
Definitions
Violence [-]
Democracy [+]
Weapons [+]
Security [-]
Democracy [-]
Weapons [-]
Security [+]
Violence [+]
UN [-]
UN [+]
Power [+]
Power [-]
Occupation [+]
Occupation [-]
Reconstruction [+]
Reconstruction [-]
See all the Reference Source
G1 Power [+]
G2 Power [-]
G3 Institution [+]
G4 Institution [-]
G5 Norms [+]
G6 Norms [-]
Terrorism [-]
Terrorism [+]
Disarmament [-]
Disarmament [+]
Preemption [+]
Preemption [-]
Freedom [+]
Freedom [-]
Oil [+]
Oil [-]

Institutionalised legitimacy is required to maintain a leader's power base

What is Global Argument.net?
Navigating these Argument Maps
Home Window - Ale
What concepts can help us to understand the war?
Who are pro war?
Who are against the war?
2003 Mar Glennon [+]
One War, Many Theories Michael Cohen
2004 mar Ignatieff [+]
2004 Nov Manne [-]
2005 Jan Kagan [+]
2004 Jun Krauthammer [+]
2002 Pollack [+]
2004 May Ash [-]
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
2003 Aug Gray [-]
2003 Dec Chomsky [-]
2003 Feb Walt [-]
2003 Nov Mann [-]
2003 Sep Gaita [-]
2004 Jul Evans [-]
2002 Sep Harries [-]
2003 Feb Mearsheimer [-]
2004 Mar Fukuyama [-]
2003 Feb Waltz K. [-]
How could the Iraq invasion be understood?
What are the war's causes?
2003 Feb Kristol [+]
2005 Jan Freedman [+]
2003 Mar Roberts [+]
2001 Elshtain [-]
2003 Nov Walzer [-]
2004 Jan Friedman [+]
2004 Feb Scruton [+]
What ethical principles are at stake?
What are the war's effects?
What is the power configuration?
What is the role of institutions?
Legitimacy [-]
Legitimacy [+]
Statistical data
Definitions
Violence [-]
Democracy [+]
Weapons [+]
Security [-]
Democracy [-]
Weapons [-]
Security [+]
Violence [+]
UN [-]
UN [+]
Power [+]
Power [-]
Occupation [+]
Occupation [-]
Reconstruction [+]
Reconstruction [-]
See all the Reference Source
G1 Power [+]
G2 Power [-]
G3 Institution [+]
G4 Institution [-]
G5 Norms [+]
G6 Norms [-]
Terrorism [-]
Terrorism [+]
Disarmament [-]
Disarmament [+]
Preemption [+]
Preemption [-]
Freedom [+]
Freedom [-]
Oil [+]
Oil [-]

nothing justifies the loss of life on both sides that the invasion entailed

Who are against the war?
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
See all the Reference Source
Who are against the war?
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
See all the Reference Source
What is Global Argument.net?
Navigating these Argument Maps
Home Window - Ale
What concepts can help us to understand the war?
Who are pro war?
Who are against the war?
2003 Mar Glennon [+]
One War, Many Theories Michael Cohen
2004 mar Ignatieff [+]
2004 Nov Manne [-]
2005 Jan Kagan [+]
2004 Jun Krauthammer [+]
2002 Pollack [+]
2004 May Ash [-]
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
2003 Aug Gray [-]
2003 Dec Chomsky [-]
2003 Feb Walt [-]
2003 Nov Mann [-]
2003 Sep Gaita [-]
2004 Jul Evans [-]
2002 Sep Harries [-]
2003 Feb Mearsheimer [-]
2004 Mar Fukuyama [-]
2003 Feb Waltz K. [-]
How could the Iraq invasion be understood?
What are the war's causes?
2003 Feb Kristol [+]
2005 Jan Freedman [+]
2003 Mar Roberts [+]
2001 Elshtain [-]
2003 Nov Walzer [-]
2004 Jan Friedman [+]
2004 Feb Scruton [+]
What ethical principles are at stake?
What are the war's effects?
What is the power configuration?
What is the role of institutions?
Legitimacy [-]
Legitimacy [+]
Statistical data
Definitions
Violence [-]
Democracy [+]
Weapons [+]
Security [-]
Democracy [-]
Weapons [-]
Security [+]
Violence [+]
UN [-]
UN [+]
Power [+]
Power [-]
Occupation [+]
Occupation [-]
Reconstruction [+]
Reconstruction [-]
See all the Reference Source
G1 Power [+]
G2 Power [-]
G3 Institution [+]
G4 Institution [-]
G5 Norms [+]
G6 Norms [-]
Terrorism [-]
Terrorism [+]
Disarmament [-]
Disarmament [+]
Preemption [+]
Preemption [-]
Freedom [+]
Freedom [-]
Oil [+]
Oil [-]

A useful summary note reviewing the different positions on the Iraq Debate represented below has bee...

2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
What are the war's effects?
G2 Power [-]
E2: US OCCUPATION
P1: CONTROL
(question)
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
G2 Power [-]
(statement)
E1: VIOLENCE
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
G2 Power [-]
(statement)
C3: SECURITY
E1: VIOLENCE
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
G2 Power [-]
(statement)
E1: VIOLENCE
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
Power [-]
G2 Power [-]
(statement)
P1: CONTROL
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
What is the power configuration?
E2: US OCCUPATION
P1: CONTROL
(question)
P3: OIL
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
Terrorism [-]

This is not the real reason for the invasion

(fact)
C2: TERRORISM
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
Legitimacy [-]
Democracy [-]
Occupation [-]
Reconstruction [-]
G2 Power [-]

Why US occupation is important? democratic election is not interesting ...

E2: US OCCUPATION
E3: RECONSTRUCTION
N1: LEGITIMACY
P2: DEMOCRACY
(hypothesis)
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
Violence [-]
Power [-]

violence in Iraq increased, this supports that US aim was not reached: promote democracy and securit...

(fact)
P1: CONTROL
E1: VIOLENCE
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
Violence [-]
Occupation [-]
Reconstruction [-]
G2 Power [-]
E2: US OCCUPATION
E3: RECONSTRUCTION
(statement)
E1: VIOLENCE
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
Occupation [-]

this comproves other implicit aims for this war (ex. economic interests)

E2: US OCCUPATION
(fact)
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
Democracy [-]
UN [-]
Occupation [-]
E2: US OCCUPATION
(statement)
P2: DEMOCRACY
I1: UNITED NATIONS
What is Global Argument.net?
Navigating these Argument Maps
Home Window - Ale
What concepts can help us to understand the war?
Who are pro war?
Who are against the war?
2003 Mar Glennon [+]
One War, Many Theories Michael Cohen
2004 mar Ignatieff [+]
2004 Nov Manne [-]
2005 Jan Kagan [+]
2004 Jun Krauthammer [+]
2002 Pollack [+]
2004 May Ash [-]
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
2003 Aug Gray [-]
2003 Dec Chomsky [-]
2003 Feb Walt [-]
2003 Nov Mann [-]
2003 Sep Gaita [-]
2004 Jul Evans [-]
2002 Sep Harries [-]
2003 Feb Mearsheimer [-]
2004 Mar Fukuyama [-]
2003 Feb Waltz K. [-]
How could the Iraq invasion be understood?
What are the war's causes?
2003 Feb Kristol [+]
2005 Jan Freedman [+]
2003 Mar Roberts [+]
2001 Elshtain [-]
2003 Nov Walzer [-]
2004 Jan Friedman [+]
2004 Feb Scruton [+]
What ethical principles are at stake?
What are the war's effects?
What is the power configuration?
What is the role of institutions?
Legitimacy [-]
Legitimacy [+]
Statistical data
Definitions
Violence [-]
Democracy [+]
Weapons [+]
Security [-]
Democracy [-]
Weapons [-]
Security [+]
Violence [+]
UN [-]
UN [+]
Power [+]
Power [-]
Occupation [+]
Occupation [-]
Reconstruction [+]
Reconstruction [-]
See all the Reference Source
G1 Power [+]
G2 Power [-]
G3 Institution [+]
G4 Institution [-]
G5 Norms [+]
G6 Norms [-]
Terrorism [-]
Terrorism [+]
Disarmament [-]
Disarmament [+]
Preemption [+]
Preemption [-]
Freedom [+]
Freedom [-]
Oil [+]
Oil [-]

Level of analysis issue becomes a problem... to conceptually organise the myriad of positions will ...

2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
What are the war's effects?
P2: DEMOCRACY
(question)
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
Occupation [-]
Terrorism [-]
E2: US OCCUPATION
P1: CONTROL
(hypothesis)
C2: TERRORISM
2003 Mar AliTarik [-]
Statistical data
Power [-]
Occupation [-]
E2: US OCCUPATION
(data)
P1: CONTROL